Internal linking for AI content goes wrong in a predictable way. An AI draft touches twenty topics, a link tool finds twenty pages that share words with them, and an editor in a hurry clicks Accept twenty times. The post ships with links that look relevant to software and send readers somewhere they did not mean to go.

This page covers the suggestion side: how the main WordPress tools pick links, what they cost, the bad suggestions they produce, and a check that takes about 30 seconds per link. The site-wide process (audits, orphan pages, hub pages, a weekly routine) is covered in Prickly Blog’s internal linking workflow for blogs.

Summary

Link suggestion tools match words, keywords or entities, so they propose links that share vocabulary with your sentence and answer a different question. Accept a suggestion only when the target answers what the anchor promises, the anchor makes sense read on its own, and the target is worth a reader’s click. Preview auto-linking rules before they run site-wide, and confirm that links inserted by JavaScript appear in the rendered HTML.

Each tool documents its method, and the method predicts its mistakes.

  • Yoast SEO Premium compares the top 20 prominent words of the post you are editing with every other post on the site, according to its internal linking suggestions page; more overlap moves a post up the list. Shared words find posts on similar subjects, and they cannot tell whether a post answers the question your sentence raises. Yoast also asks you to check whether the tool supports your language.
  • Rank Math PRO runs AI Link Genius. Its knowledge base describes a Link Opportunities panel that shows each suggested link with its surrounding text, and keyword maps that turn a keyword and its variations into links across existing posts, and new ones too when Auto-link on publish is on. AI can generate extra variations for a map, and the default cap is 3 links per post.
  • Link Whisper suggests links inside the editor. The free version gives suggestions you copy and paste; Premium adds links in bulk with the anchor already chosen, an orphan report and auto-linking. The FAQ on its pricing page says it changes your content only when you switch on auto-linking with keyword rules you set.
  • All in One SEO (AIOSEO) puts Link Assistant in its Pro plan and above: contextual suggestions, an anchor text generator and bulk insertion across pages.
  • InLinks maps pages to entities (people, places, concepts) and, per its internal linking tool page, injects the links with JavaScript instead of editing the content in your CMS.

Which AI internal linking tools are worth a look, and what do they cost?

Prices come from each vendor’s own pricing or product page, checked 5 Nov 2026. Where the vendor says so, they exclude VAT.

ToolHow suggestions appearInserts links by itself?PriceCheck after it runs
Yoast SEO PremiumSidebar list ranked by shared prominent wordsNo, you drag or copy each link€118.80 a year ex VATA wrong page with similar vocabulary
Rank Math PRO (AI Link Genius)Link Opportunities panel; keyword mapsYes, keyword maps after Preview & execute$8.99 a month billed yearly; $5.59 during the sale running on 5 Nov 2026The same anchor from one map across many posts
Link WhisperSuggestions in the editorPremium: bulk add and auto-linking rulesFree plugin; Starter $97 a year for 1 site with 2,000 AI credits; 14-day money-back guaranteeAnchors picked for you in bulk
AIOSEO Pro (Link Assistant)Suggestions with generated anchorsYes, bulk insertion$199.50 for the first year, normally $399, 10 sites; renewals at full priceGenerated anchors that read like keywords
InLinksEntity matches across a projectYes, injected with JavaScriptFrom US$49 a month for 100 pagesWhether the links show in the rendered HTML

The cheapest working setup costs nothing: Link Whisper’s free plugin for suggestions plus the check below. Pay for bulk tools only when one-by-one review of hundreds of posts becomes the bottleneck, and then review the preview list before anything goes live.

Seven patterns cover most rejected suggestions. Each has a test an editor can run without any tool.

ProblemExampleTest that catches it
Right words, wrong page“pricing” in a sentence about tool prices links to a post on pricing psychologyOpen the target: does it answer the sentence?
Wrong intentA how-to sentence links to a services pageWould a reader of this sentence want to buy right now?
Over-optimised anchor“best AI SEO writing tool for small teams” as the linked wordsRead the anchor alone: does it sound like a person wrote it?
Thin or doomed targetA 300-word stub, or a page on the merge listCheck its length and the refresh log
Duplicate targetTwo links to one page within three paragraphsOne link per target per post, at the first useful mention
Redirected targetA link to an old slug that now returns a 301Hover: does the URL match the final address?
Link in the wrong placeA link inside an H2 or in the first sentence of the answerHeadings and the opening answer stay link-free

How do you check one suggestion in 30 seconds?

Five questions, in order. A no at any step ends the check with a reject or an edit.

  1. Does the target answer what the anchor promises? Open it in a new tab and read its first screen. If the anchor says “AI SEO editing checklist”, the page had better be the checklist.
  2. Does the anchor make sense out of context? This is Google’s own test from its link documentation: read only the linked words and ask whether you can tell what the page is about.
  3. Is the target the page that owns this topic on your site? If two of your pages fit, link the one you want to rank, every time.
  4. Is the target worth the click? Indexed, current, longer than a stub, and absent from the merge list.
  5. Does the sentence still read well? If the link forces you to rewrite the sentence around it, the link belongs in another sentence.

Then mark it: accept, edit the anchor, or reject. Keep a tally per post. When more than half of a tool’s suggestions get rejected, its settings (or your list of pages) need attention before the next batch.

How do you audit the anchors AI tools added across a site?

Bulk and auto-linking tools repeat themselves. A keyword map that links “AI content brief” to one page uses that phrase as the anchor in every post that mentions it, up to its per-post cap. Spot the pattern with a crawl, because Search Console’s Links report shows link text only for links from other sites.

  1. Crawl the site with Screaming Frog (free up to 500 URLs) and use Bulk Export > All inlinks, which lists every link with its anchor text, as the user guide describes. The Links tab also flags non-descriptive internal anchors such as “click here”.
  2. Pivot the export by target URL and anchor, counting rows.
  3. For each target, flag any anchor that makes up more than half of its internal links, and any anchor longer than 8 words.
  4. Rewrite the flagged anchors in the posts where they fit worst, so each anchor belongs to its sentence.
  5. For links added by JavaScript, crawl with JavaScript rendering on and read the Unique JS Inlinks column, which the Screaming Frog user guide defines as links found only in the rendered HTML.

The 50% and 8-word limits are Copycat house rules. Google’s documentation sets no number; it warns against cramming keywords into anchors, and the limits give editors a line to act on.

A chat model that has never seen your site can only guess your URLs. Give it the list and forbid anything outside it, the “external knowledge restriction” that Anthropic recommends in its guide to reducing hallucinations.

Prepare a sheet with four columns per published page: URL, title, a one-line summary and the query the page owns. Paste it with the draft and this prompt:

“Below are a draft inside <draft> tags and a list of our published pages inside <pages> tags. Suggest up to 6 internal links for the draft. Use only URLs from <pages>, and never write a URL that is missing from the list. For each suggestion give the exact sentence, the words to link (2 to 6 words taken from that sentence), the target URL, and one line on what the reader gets from the target. Skip sentences where no page fits, write NONE if nothing fits at all, and never suggest two links to the same URL.”

Then validate in two minutes: every URL must match a row in your sheet exactly, and every target must load with a 200 status. The one-line reasons speed up the 30-second check, because a vague reason flags a weak link.

What should you check before turning on auto-linking?

Auto-linking writes links into many posts at once, so one bad rule repeats everywhere. Before switching it on:

  • Preview every change. Rank Math’s keyword maps show a Preview & execute list where you untick the links you do not want, and a Rollback option undoes a map after it runs.
  • Set the cap. Rank Math turns the first 3 matches per post into links by default. One per map per post is plenty for a blog.
  • Decide on new posts. Auto-link on publish applies the map to future posts too. Leave it off until a map has run cleanly on existing ones.
  • Exclude pages. Partner pages, legal pages and anything with agreed anchor text stay out of every rule.
  • Check JavaScript links. Google’s link documentation asks you to use the URL Inspection tool to confirm that anchor text inserted by JavaScript is present in the rendered HTML. Do it on three pages after InLinks or any script-based tool goes live.
  • Know what happens if you cancel. Link Whisper writes links into the WordPress database, so they stay after you cancel. Links injected by a script exist only while the script loads.

Worked example: 20 suggestions on one AI draft

Example: a 1,600-word AI draft about editing AI SEO articles. The link tool proposes 20 links, and the editor runs the 30-second check on each.

OutcomeCountReason
Accepted as suggested5The target answers the sentence and the anchor reads naturally
Accepted with a new anchor3The tool used the target’s full keyword phrase
Rejected: wrong page5Shared words, different question
Rejected: thin or merge-bound target3Two stubs under 400 words, one page on the merge list
Rejected: second link to the same target2Kept the first useful mention
Rejected: redirected URL1Old slug, now a 301 to a newer page
Rejected: link inside an H21Headings stay link-free
Total208 links kept

Time: 20 checks at 30 seconds is 10 minutes, plus about a minute each to rewrite 3 anchors, so 13 minutes for the post. The draft ends with 8 links, one per 200 words (1,600 / 8), each pointing at the page that owns its topic.

Skipping the check saves those 13 minutes and leaves 12 bad links on the page. At the same rate, a batch of 40 AI posts carries 480 bad links (12 x 40) that someone has to find later.

Links get checked when a draft is edited, when an old page is refreshed, and when the brief plans them.

Related

AI SEO editing checklist: weak links are one of the line-by-line checks before publishing

Related

refresh old content with AI: fixing old links is part of every AI-assisted refresh

Related

AI SEO content workflow: where the link step sits between draft and publish

Related

SEO content brief template: plan the links in the brief so the draft leaves room for them

FAQ

Is Yoast’s free plugin enough for internal link suggestions?

The suggestions belong to Yoast SEO Premium, at €118.80 a year ex VAT when checked on 5 Nov 2026. The free plugin has the text link counter, which shows links in and out per post and is enough to find posts that nothing links to.

Does Google see internal links added with JavaScript?

Google’s link documentation says to check JavaScript-inserted anchor text with the URL Inspection tool and make sure it is present in the rendered HTML. InLinks states that its injected links are crawlable; confirm it on your own pages after setup.

Should AI choose the anchor text?

Let it propose, then edit. Generated anchors start from the target’s topic and turn into keyword phrases that sound odd mid-sentence. Keep the suggested target, take 2 to 6 words from your own sentence as the anchor, and read it out of context before saving.

How many AI-suggested links should one post keep?

Google says there is no magical ideal number. A useful ceiling is one link per 200 words of body text, and only where the target answers what the sentence raises; the worked example on this page kept 8 of 20 suggestions for that reason.

Can I undo links an auto-linking tool added?

Rank Math’s keyword maps have a Rollback option in Link Genius. Link Whisper links sit in your posts as normal links, so they stay until you remove them. For any other tool, take a WordPress backup before the first bulk run.

What should you do with your next AI draft?

Before you accept a single suggestion, run the 30-second check on the first five and count how many pass. If fewer than three do, fix the tool’s settings or your page list before linking the rest.